Home > Bold Faith Type > Will Catholic Bishops Stand up to Paul Ryan?

Will Catholic Bishops Stand up to Paul Ryan?

April 11, 2011, 4:17 pm | Posted by John Gehring

johnaryan.jpgRep. Paul Ryan of Wisconsin, the intellectual darling of the Republican Party, has proposed a 2012 budget plan that would end Medicare and Medicaid as we know it. Ryan frames his dismantling of bedrock social safety nets as a “moral imperative” to save us from spiraling debt. House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, pushing the plan this weekend, callously argues that “we have a safety net in place in this country for people who frankly don’t need one.”

Simply put, seniors and vulnerable families are being used as pawns in an ideological agenda whose end game is nothing less than wiping away the New Deal. Given that Ryan, a Catholic, has claimed the moral high ground, I’m challenging Catholic bishops to revive the legacy of another Ryan and speak out against this draconian proposal.

In 1919, the U.S. Catholic bishops recruited Monsignor John Ryan, a Catholic priest whose thinking on labor and social inequality were widely read in the decades following World War I, to write their Program for Social Reconstruction – a bold plan for what at the time were visionary social reforms: minimum wages, public housing for workers, labor participation in management decisions, and insurance for the elderly, disabled and unemployed. The bishops’ proposal and Ryan’s rising star in Washington laid the groundwork for New Deal legislation proposed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in the following decades. Time magazine described the “Right Rev. New Dealer” as “U.S. Catholicism’s most potent social reformer.” Where is this Catholic voice today?

Bishops were influential (and controversial) actors during recent legislative battles over health care reform. They clearly have the stomach for tough political fights. Will they now take on Paul Ryan and a Republican Party pursuing a radical agenda that is antithetical to a Catholic vision of the common good?

Photo credit to the John A. Ryan Institute at the University of St. Thomas

2 Responses to “Will Catholic Bishops Stand up to Paul Ryan?”

  1. Tim O'Neill says:

    What disturbs me the most about Mr. Ryan is his adherence to the principles of Ayn Rand, the noted Atheist. In fact, Mr Ryan makes his staff read Ayn Rand’s books. Ayn Rands philosophy is opposite to Catholic Social Teachings. I would like to know how Mr Ryan can justify following such an anti-christian author.

  2. Mark J. McPherson says:

    We may have an early answer to this question, in Dolan’s fawning letter to Ryan.