Dan Nejfelt, Faith in Public Life’s Senior Editor and Training Coordinator, worked at Sojourners magazine as part of his graduate study of journalism at the University of Missouri before coming to FPL. Prior to that, he taught remedial reading and writing to 7th and 8th graders in rural Arkansas as a Teach For America corps member. Dan blogs about health care, the Religious Right and budget issues.
Media Matters has an important new report about the alarming frequency with which leaders of the Family Research Council appear on cable news shows. You might ask why that’s a big deal. As the report spells out, it’s because FRC regularly traffics in false, demonizing rhetoric about the LGBT community.
Since being designated a hate group by the highly respected Southern Poverty Law Center in November 2010, FRC staff have appeared on Fox News, CNN and MSNBC 52 times. Only two of those segments mentioned FRC’s designation as a hate group. (Despite FRC’s claims to the contrary, the SPLC designation stated “Viewing homosexuality as unbiblical does not qualify organizations for listing as hate groups.”)
A few notable hateful, misleading claims by FRC leaders cited in the Media Matters report:
- The “It Gets Better” Project is a disgusting and “part of a concerted effort to persuade kids that homosexuality is okay and actually to recruit them into that ‘lifestyle.’”
- “The ‘Research is Overwhelming’ that gay men are more likely to molest children.”
- “Senators Who Vote For [Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell] Repeal Will Have ‘The Blood Of Innocent Soldiers On Their Hands.’”
In addition to these examples, we’ve also noted FRC’s willingness to make inflammatory false claims on a variety of issues, such as:
Having diverse viewpoints in the news media is important. But so are accuracy and credibility. Giving FRC an elevated platform in the public debate on critical issues implicitly extends to them an image of honesty and integrity they simply do not deserve. Kudos to Media Matters for so thoroughly cataloguing this problem.
add a comment »
As the economy relegates social issues to the back-burner, Religious Right leaders are baptizing the Tea Party’s agenda of punishing the vulnerable in order to further enrich the wealthiest Americans. Toward this end, Tony Perkins wrote a post on CNN’s Belief Blog this week arguing that “Jesus was a free-marketer.”
To make this point, Perkins offers a noncontextual exegesis of the parable of the ten minas in Luke 19. Rather than a figurative lesson about using Spiritual gifts to grow the church, Perkins interprets the story as proof that God rewards industrious businesspeople with fantastic wealth and punishes lazy people. He also offers this dubious, troubling description of the nature of our modern capitalist society:
Jesus rejected collectivism and the mentality that has occupied America for the last few decades: that everyone gets a trophy – equal outcomes for inequitable performance. There are winners and yes, there are losers. And wins and losses are determined by the diligence and determination of the individual. [emphasis added]
This, in a nutshell, is what I call The Big Lie about our economic system – the argument that everyone gets what they deserve, that poverty and prosperity alike are truly earned.
Taken to its logical conclusion, Perkins’s argument means that there was a sudden massive collapse of individual work ethic in Fall of 2008 that led to millions of layoffs. It concludes that those who currently can’t find work have only themselves to blame (never mind the fact that job-seekers outnumber job openings more than 4-to-1). Perkins’s argument suggests that a difference in work ethic is what keeps 49 million Americans in poverty and allocates to the richest 400 Americans more wealth than the bottom 50 percent. In other words, it’s pure fantasy that serves no other purpose than to deny the existence of economic injustice.
Perkins also clearly argues that this system is not inevitably sinful:
Some would argue that such an approach encourages abuses, the likes of which we have seen on Wall Street. While some egregious abuses have taken place, they are not inevitable or intrinsic to free enterprise. [emphasis added]
This claim ignores that corruption and predatory practices are ubiquitous features of not only free-market capitalism, but also the entirety of human history. I’m sure Perkins recognizes that we are a fallen people, but his economic philosophy doesn’t seem to square with this belief.
Two immutable aspects of human nature are that we have a strong desire to pursue narrow self-interest, but are also social beings who seek the moral approval of our neighbors. Free-market capitalism, in theory, reconciles these impulses by harnessing our selfishness in a way that establishes an inherently fair economic and social order. The problem, in practice, is that it simply doesn’t work. The continued prosperity of the bankers whose greed crashed the economy and the ongoing hardships faced by teachers and nurses who’ve lost their jobs through no fault of their own, are but two small pieces of evidence.
I don’t mean to imply that hard work has nothing to do with prosperity. It absolutely does. I know of many very rich people who work very hard, and have also met poor people who don’t. But the inverse is also true. Reducing success and failure to consequences of personal virtues is foolish at best and dishonest at worst. And Perkins should be ashamed of himself for using the Bible to perpetuate this myth.
add a comment »
Family Research Council President Tony Perkins, who has an extensive record of lying about and hatefully attacking people with whom he disagrees, outdid himself recently when he accused President Obama of having “disdain for Christianity” and said Christians who voted for him in 2008 should repent (which pretty clearly implies that he believes supporting Obama was a sin).
This smear not only maligns the President in service of a political agenda, but also insults Christians who believe faith doesn’t belong to one party. Such charges are not only arrogant, ignorant and cynical, they promote a theologically dangerous commingling of faith and partisanship.
Politics is by no means a vocation for the thin-skinned, but some lines of attack are inexcusable. Perkins’s accusation definitely falls into that category. Even though Perkins exhibits unChristian characteristics of dishonesty, hate and cynicism in the service of an agenda that promotes bigotry, exalts greed and inflicts suffering on the powerless, I would never call his faith fake.
Perkins should have the decency to give the President and people who supported him the same respect. In his rush to point out the speck he perceives in Obama’s eye, Perkins misses the log in his own.
add a comment »
Tim King has a great post over at God’s Politics identifying a core flaw of our nation’s economic debate:
If you didn’t watch last night’s [GOP] debate, I’ll save you some time and sum it up for you in seven words and a em dash.
Taxes and regulations — we’ve got too many.
Now, this isn’t surprising. Last year, in President Obama’s State of the Union address, he talked about cutting bureaucratic red tape and reviewing regulations that would hurt businesses.
What was missing from the GOP debate was a discussion of consumer demand.
Tim goes on to cite a McClatchy study revealing that small business owners are being held back not by onerous government red tape, but rather by lack of consumer demand. He then makes the important connection that government programs can help address this problem.
The good news is our country can tackle poverty and the lack of demand in the market at the same time. According to a report by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities the effect of the 2009 Recovery Act:
- Expansions in the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Child Tax Credit (CTC) kept 1.6 million people out of poverty.
- The Making Work Pay tax credit, which expired at the end of 2010, kept another 1.5 million people out of poverty.
- Expansions in the duration and level of unemployment insurance benefits kept 3.4 million people out of poverty.
- Expansions in SNAP benefits kept 1.0 million people out of poverty
That means nearly 7 million people have been kept out of poverty, but it also means 7 million people have been boosting consumer demand.
This chart from Moody’s elaborates further:
I’ll add two things:
- Tim wasn’t cherry-picking the McClatchy investigation about demand rather government regulations’ effect on small businesses. The AP, CNN, the Wall Street Journal, the Economic Policy Institute and the New York Times’ Bruce Bartlett all came to similar conclusions, drawing on Bureau of Labor Statistics data and business surveys.
- Conservatives attack the programs Tim correctly identified as stimulants of demand. In addition to talking points about the supposed failure of the 2009 stimulus, folks on the right decry the fact that many Americans don’t have an income tax burden even though tax credits that contribute to this reality – like the EITC, CTC and Making Work Pay tax credits — keep low-wage earners from being taxed into poverty.
When you hear religious right leaders talk about job-killing regulations or the injustice of too many people not paying income taxes, remember that they either aren’t telling the truth, aren’t doing the math, or aren’t honoring Christian teachings on poverty.
add a comment »
The success of the campaign to repeal SB-5 yesterday was a significant achievement for the faith community in Ohio. As we’ve noted before, religious leaders and organizations were part of the statewide opposition to SB-5 from the beginning. Most notably, over Labor Day Weekend clergy across the state preached in their places of worship about their faiths’ teaching about workers’ rights and against SB-5. Faith leaders also took part in the signature drive to get repeal put on the ballot, spoke at press conferences, and organized and delivered petitions to state lawmakers regarding the importance of protecting the rights of working families.
Polls also showed that religious voters disagreed with the law’s restrictions on collective bargaining rights. A Quinnipiac poll in May showed that a majority of evangelicals favored repeal of SB-5, and a poll commissioned by FPL and conducted by Public Policy Polling in March showed that strong majorities of Catholics and evangelicals thought restricting collective bargaining for public employees was the wrong thing to do.
FPL was also part of the movement to reject SB-5′s politically motivated attack on the rights of teachers, nurses, law enforcement officers and firefighters. We worked with We Believe Ohio, Catholics United, We are Ohio, and a number of other national and Ohio-based organizations to elevate religious support for worker justice and to condemn reckless political power-grabs and schemes to give corporate special interests huge tax breaks at the expense of everyone else. We Believe Ohio’s Rev. Tim Ahrens, an FPL board member, summed up the victory quite well:
Hundreds of thousands of Ohioans have fought long and hard for the past 11 months to reverse the river of a right-wing attack on working men and women and their families. We have overcome lies and deceptions to do so. As people of faith, we need to remember that labor and economic questions are fundamentally religious questions. There are no purely spiritual interests in our times that are not made manifest in the everyday life of working people. Every day real working people get up, pray, walk out their door and give us their best. They return to their families exhausted from serving. That is spirituality made manifest. That is faith beyond belief.
As people of faith, we will make mistakes in tangling with such critical issues. But, the greatest mistake we could make is ignoring them and acting as if they do not matter. Nothing matters more than working shoulder to shoulder with the men and women who teach our children, patrol our city streets, save us from the real fires of our times. Despite the lies and deceptions, Ohioans know this. We will never abandon those who care for us and serve us with love and devotion.
add a comment »